Mother hanging baby clothes on clothesline with toddler in golden hour light

Secondhand, First Choice

Saving Big on Baby Gear Without the Stress

Sierra James

Sierra James

Postpartum Support Specialist & Infant Wellness Guide

02/12/2025

Let's breathe, mama. Breathe in all of your hopes that everything will be ideal and pristine, and then exhale that pressure for all to be perfect and new. The reality is, your baby doesn't care whether that swing was straight out of the boutique or from a loving neighbor just blocks away. What matters is the love, care, thought and love that inhabits your space. And if you're anything like so many of us who eye the price of baby gear and suddenly feel the increasingly familiar flutter of anxiety in your chest, please know that you are so not alone.

Opting for previously owned doesn't mean compromising. It means you are stepping into your power as a mindful, resourceful parent. You're choosing community over consumerism, wisdom over waste, and comfort over comparison. In a society that teaches us to throw the old away, that our value is in the newness of our things, you're rewriting the story — that what's loved once can be loved again — beautifully, safely and affordably.

Why It's Smart to Buy Secondhand First

There's a quiet wisdom in buying the second best. Lots of baby gear is only employed for a short season of life, frequently ending up in like-new condition by the time it's passed to the next child. And let's be real: burp-ups and blowouts aside, your baby is going to do their worst to break things in, regardless of the price tag.

Mother examining baby carrier in nursery

Choosing secondhand isn't about shortcuts — it's about opportunities. Doors to savings, the future, and a warm community. Doors opening to stories and to support, too, from other parents who've walked this path before you. It's a gentle revolution, mama, and you're already involved.

Here's What's Safe (and What's Not) to Buy Used

Not all baby gear items are created equal when it comes to buying secondhand. Here, a gentle guide to what's generally safe to buy used — and what deserves a fresh start.

Safe to buy secondhand baby items laid out on wooden surface

Good to Go Used:

  • Clothes & Shoes: They outgrow clothes so fast and use their clothes one or two times. Seek clothes with no stains or smells. Pro tip: opt for zippers over snaps when possible — you'll be glad you did get 3 a.m.
  • Swaddles, Blankets & Bibs: They can be sanitized by cleaning in hot water with baby-safe detergent.
  • Toys (non-plush): Sturdy hard plastic or silicone toys make great secondhand purchases. Simply sanitize thoroughly with a vinegar solution or mild disinfectant.
  • Strollers & High Chairs: Though I would always confirm that there are no recalls, missing parts, or structural integrity issues, it's perfectly okay to purchase these items secondhand.
  • Baby Carriers: Seams, buckles and other wear should be examined. And a favorite carrier can still deliver these same comforting snuggles.
  • Nursery Furniture: Before you buy baby end tables, you should know that dressers and changing tables are not short term pieces. For cribs, make sure it complies with current safety standards (check for slat spacing and that it has not been recalled).

Better Bought New:

  • Car Seats: Safety first. Car seats have expiration dates (typically 6 years) and should not be used if they have been in a crash.
  • Crib Mattresses: Mold and Bacteria They are so difficult to see. And new is the way to go for peace of mind.
  • Breast Pumps: Closed-system breast pumps can be more safely found secondhand, but make sure to purchase new tubing and parts.
  • Pacifiers & Bottle Nipples: These wear down over time—replenish them for hygiene and safety.

Where to Secondhand-Shop With Confidence

Secondhand need not be sketchy. There are so many good places you can trust to find beautiful gently-used treasures:

  • Facebook Marketplace & Buy Nothing Groups: Local, often free, and full of parents who are waiting to pay it forward. Meet in public and check the items in broad daylight.
  • Once Upon a Child: A curated baby gear (clean and gently-used) goldmine. Many locations do safety checks.
  • Local Thrift & Consignment Stores: Treasures are hiding. Actually, weekdays are worth checking out for less traffic and a better selection.
  • Garage Sales & Community Swaps: Like a farmers' market for gently used stuff, practice bringing cash, a tape measure and the willingness to talk to your fellow parents.
  • Online Platforms (Kidizen, Mercari, Poshmark): Find sellers with strong ratings and make sure listings are thorough. Ask questions before buying.

Clean It Like You Mean It

Before anything comes into contact with your baby, it's got to have your magic touch. Here's how to give those secondhand finds a loving refresh:

  • Hard Toys & Gear: Clean with 50/50 vinegar and water solution or baby-safe disinfectant solution. Special attention should be paid to edges, corners and hard-to-reach surfaces.
  • Clothing & Linens: Hot wash with fragrance free detergent. Hang in the sun to dry whenever possible (which naturally lifts stains and disinfects).
  • Strollers, High Chairs and Carriers: Vacuum out any crumbs, remove covers to wash if you are able to, and check for any odors or grime that lingers.

Thoughtful Ways to Make It Work

  • Establish a Running Wishlist: Keep a memo on your phone of things you need to buy so you don't buy on impulse just because it's a deal.
  • Establish Your Budget: Even used can rack up. Figure out how much you want to spend for each category.
  • Trust Your Gut: If it feels sketchy, skip. No deal is worth your sanity.
  • Lean on Community: Ask the veteran moms where they've found gems. You would not believe how much wisdom exists within your own circle.

Trust Yourself, Mama

You are creating your baby's world with love and purpose. Whether your nursery is packed with vintage treasures or new-from-the-box splurges, it's the love that fills those four walls that matters most. You're not doing this wrong. In fact, you're doing it with care, courage and connection.

You're not alone. Each lovingly chosen secondhand item has a story. Each dollar you save is a silent benefit to the years ahead. And every love-based choice you make? That's the real luxury.

✨ Mantra to hold onto:

"I am enough. What I provide for my baby is sufficient. Love makes it whole."

Tags: